The Life in My Years

An anthology of life

“That’s not who we are,” said the politician. It may have been a member of Congress, a governor or a local sheriff. Certainly I’ve heard Barack Obama say it.

“That’s not who we are.”

That statement of denial, a far too late attempt to pick up the shattered and scattered pieces of our national reputation, usually follows some act that stoked widespread outrage; a(nother) school shooting, a bombed mosque, a right wing rally that devolves into violence, an outrageous statement that stokes violence against some marginalized group (You know, like immigrants eating pets).

Invariably a politician who hasn’t met a microphone he doesn’t love, stands in front of a crowd or tells a panel of CNN pundits, “That’s not who we are,” and I reply to the television, “The fuck it’s not.

This – is – exactly – who – we – are.

This election night I decided to spare myself the angst. We watched a documentary, and then an episode of The Sopranos (no, didn’t see the series the first time) and then took a peek at the returns. Even early on, it looked bleak.

“Fuck it. I’m not watching this” I told my wife. “I’m going to bed.”

I took an Ativan and nodded right off.

Woke up at 2:45 when the drugs wore off and saw the CNN headline, Trump wins!

So yeah, I don’t think there’s any doubt about who we are.

America is a fascist country. America is a stupid country. America is myopic.

There are no excuses. This country has lived through, and put the world through, nine years of Trump. We lived the nightmare, barely survived it, watched an insurrection, and over the past two years we’ve watched Donald Trump run a campaign that could have been plucked right out of Hitler’s Mein Kampf.

Trump made no bones about his racism, his fascism, his fascination with autocrats. He accused immigrants from Asia, Africa, South America and countries of color of poisoning America’s blood. He’s promised another travel ban and has gone one further and said that he would bar Palestinian refugees from coming to the U.S. (I hope some of you readers will take special note of this one). Despite his denials, Trump’s fingerprints have been all over Project 2025.

And despite all of the signs that said, DON’T GO THERE, Americans decided that Trumpism is the direction that they want the country to take. There are no excuses. No, “This is not who we are,” to fall back on. “This is not who we are,” is as hollow as last weeks rotting Halloween Jack-o’-lantern.

This – is – exactly – who – we – are.

When the ICE raids begin, when the deportation camps are in full operation, when more and more women bleed out for not receiving reproductive care, when gay rights are overturned, when Ukraine falls, when we leave the Paris accords (again), when the EPA is gutted and the Department of Education is dismantled, when protests are quashed, and unfriendly media outlets shut down, when Mike Flynn and Stephen Miller and RFK and Vivek Ramaswamy are given cabinet positions, when the Supreme Court becomes even more extreme, when the administration goes after perceived enemies, when people die or go broke because of lack of healthcare coverage, and when Trump makes good on all of his promises, please, please spare us the, “That’s not who are.”

This – is – exactly – who – we – are.

It is. Because we either chose it all willingly, or we didn’t repudiate it forcefully enough, or out of some fit of pique we decided to allow it.

To those who voted for Trump. I don’t even know what to say. You voted for a fascist because you’re paying a buck more that you’d like for a dozen eggs? I’m at a loss except to say that after nine years if it never sunk in for you, if the vile rhetoric and the terms “vermin,” and “poisoning the blood,” and threats made to political opponents didn’t repel you, didn’t recall Germany in the 1920s and 1930s then, well, you must be a fascist. Looking forward to getting a fitting for that starched and pressed brown shirt?

To those who chose not to vote at all because, well, just because, “I’m above it all.” Grow the fuck up.

To those whose “conscience” “forced” them to vote for Cornel West of Jill Stein or withhold a presidential vote, I hope that the moment when you consummated your decision was delicious, savory, sweet and the political masturbation downright orgasmic. Hold onto that feeling for as long as can because it’s going to take a painful, and bitter turn when the people who you thought you were helping begin to fare worse than they already are and the walls start to come down on every other marginalized person in the world who you turned your back on when you made your decision. Two years into the nightmare, please spare us the, “Oops,” and please, during these next few days, don’t try to salve our wounds that you helped to create.

I’m appalled but not at all surprised because whenever a politician has said, “This is not who we are,” I’ve always known that it is who we are. And now, we proved it. Twice we’ve etched it onto ballots.

Cora and I just returned from a trip to Europe and I was already trying to decide where we should go next. I don’t think I can do that now – visit another country. As an American, whose country just chose an unapologetic, science denying, lying, fascist to be its leader, I think I would be too ashamed.

I’m ashamed and appalled to say, Donald Trump is exactly who we are.

*Banner image is of a mural in Boston painted by the street artist Banksy,

15 thoughts on “This Is Who We Are

  1. eden baylee's avatar eden baylee says:

    Yours is the first thing I’m reading this bleak morning. As you know I’d reached out to say good night yesterday …. but I went to bed not knowing.

    Now I know.

    You are not part of the ‘we’ in the “This is who we are”. I understand the sentiment, but you didn’t vote for tRump. You live in a country where the system and many of its citizens have allowed him to get into power. It will be chaos, and that’s what they want.

    I wish I could give you a hug, but I’m sending a virtual one. You are always welcome here, always.

    xo

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Paul's avatar Paul says:

      Hello Eden, That I didn’t vote for Trump doesn’t mean that I don’t wear the national stain. I’m kind of short on words this morning. Thank you for the kind words.

      Liked by 1 person

      1. eden baylee's avatar eden baylee says:

        “That I didn’t vote for Trump doesn’t mean that I don’t wear the national stain.” < I know.

        And because I know you, I don’t paint you with the same brush as all Americans, certainly not the ones who voted for tRump

        Liked by 1 person

  2. Anne Sandler's avatar Anne Sandler says:

    I also woke up to the news this morning. I can’t believe this is who we are. We drove across country in our 5th wheel during the Obama presidency and I realized how divided a nation we are. Once Trump got in, it was worse. And now? I used to be proud to say I was an American.

    Liked by 2 people

    1. Paul's avatar Paul says:

      After having my own road trips, I have to say that I’m not surprised by the outcome. Disappointed. Disgusted. Not surprised.

      Liked by 1 person

  3. Toonsarah's avatar Toonsarah says:

    That is who some of you are, maybe, but not all. We had an interesting conversation with an Uber driver in Las Vegas, Cuban by birth. He asked who we favoured for the election and I said Harris. He then proceeded to slag off Trump, saying he was a crook and not mentally stable (as far as I understood his broken English and bits of Spanish), before saying that despite disliking him, he would be voting for him as he believed he would be better for the economy. By economy he meant inflation of course. Paying more for a dozen eggs is a big deal for some people if they’re barely scraping by, and judging by that conversation with our driver can outweigh other considerations. Far too many, like him, either didn’t see the bigger picture or ignored it in favour of what they believe will be a cheaper shopping trip. I strongly suspect they’ve been duped in that respect as inflation has been driven by circumstances outside any one country’s control, with the exception probably of Russia, but from what I’ve seen of them, most MAGA types aren’t aware of anything happening on the world stage or understanding of the fact that what one country does affects others.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Paul's avatar Paul says:

      Hello Sarah, “He then proceeded to slag off Trump, saying he was a crook and not mentally stable (as far as I understood his broken English and bits of Spanish), before saying that despite disliking him, he would be voting for him as he believed he would be better for the economy.” Well, there you go, that’s our electorate in a nutshell. I’m trusting the guy who’s off his rocker to solve an economic crisis that renowned economists argue over.
      “… most MAGA types aren’t aware of anything happening on the world stage or understanding of the fact that what one country does affects others.” If Trump has any one single talent, it’s his ability to identify people who are so dumb they’d lose a debate with a tree stump, and then succesfully hornswoggle them.
      As H.L. Mencken once said, “No one ever went broke underestimating the intelligence of the American people.”
      Thank you for reading and commenting.
      Paul

      Liked by 1 person

  4. annieasksyou's avatar annieasksyou says:

    I prefer to think this election was the last gasp of those who hate the fact that we are becoming a multiracial, multiethnic society. I cringe that our 250th anniversary will be presided over by the felonious traitor—or, more likely—his repulsive VP. But if we are angry enough and determined enough, this unfolding horror show will be temporary. I have to believe that, hard though it may be right now.

    Like

    1. Paul's avatar Paul says:

      Hello Annie, I’m sorry for the late response. When your comment arrived I’d decided to go into a short exile. I think that the results show less of a last gasp of racists and more a disturbing malaise and dissatisfaction and overall lack of sophistication and a lack of careful consideration about the issues. Harris received far fewer votes than Biden in 2020, and Trump didn’t make any sweeping gains (I understand that I’m responding to your comment with the advantage of seeing one week worth of numbers).

      If I’m to believe some of the pundits, and I’m having more and more trouble taking them seriously, voters were angry because Harris and the Democrats weren’t “speaking to them.” The “stench of woke,” said James Carville. DEI in the workplace is worse than RFK running healthcare?

      Voters stayed home because they couldn’t sort out the differences between a serious candidate and a nutjob? Anger over the administration’s responsiblity for the higher price of eggs (a false perception) cutting into the latte budget?

      I get it that people feel like they’re hurting. My wife and I have had to make the sacrifices. A T-bone steak is a special occasion dinner. Replacing it with salads or whatever we find that’s on sale is a better trade off than voting for a guy who’s promising to to bring steak back to the table but in reality is going to take a sledge hammer to it. What I don’t get is the decision that it’s okay to vote for an adjudicated rapist because you think he’s going to cure your economic woes, and to cast that vote, based not on some research but on a knee jerk reaction. It’s discouraging and doesn’t bode well for the future. Voters are making decisions based more on Facebook than fact and I don’t see that changing.
      Thank you for reading and commenting
      Paul

      Liked by 1 person

  5. annieasksyou's avatar annieasksyou says:

    Hi, Pail. Please see my response to your comment on my post. This is all very perplexing.

    Like

  6. selizabryangmailcom's avatar selizabryangmailcom says:

    That’s exactly what I said to a friend of mine. My husband and I can’t afford Taco Bell anymore either (we got lunch from there several weeks ago and it was almost $30) but I’d rather live off of beans and rice and chicken than vote for someone who has no inner light, only darkness, and means great harm to most of us. Unfortunately, it is who we are, in the end, because it feels like that road brought us here. If the country started a certain way–in the darkness of slavery and genocide–then wasn’t it inevitable for us to eventually return full circle? I hope it’s the darkness before the dawn, though. I may not see it. But maybe in a few more generations…?

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Paul's avatar Paul says:

      Thirty bucks for Taco Hell? Daa-yumm

      Most of us have struggled with higher prices. Or, maybe I should say that many of us THINK we’ve been struggling. My wife and I go out for dinner and lunch less. Steak is a once every couple months treat. With the onset of colder weather (in SF?) we layer more and use the heater less. More house brands and fewer name brands. Anyone who thinks that those trade offs are a struggle maybe should learn what a struggle really is. And when the new administration takes over they may just find out what real pain is. And if they voted for Trump or sat it out or cast a vote for someone else then maybe they deserve a little pain.

      So yes, for many, it comes down to a choice. Some personal inconvenience and greater good, or, I’ve got mine.

      I don’t know that I’m sold on the inevitability argument. Our past is dark. Our past has some lights. We’re following some pretty horrible policies right now (support of Israel’s scorched earth war for one). And I don’t disbelieve the theories in The 1619 Project.

      All of that being said, I think that what the election of Trump shows us is that Americans are lazy and choose to be uniformed or they are just plain stupid (yes that’s a strong, often inappropriate word). Trump didn’t get a sweeping mandate. Harris just didn’t get enough votes and that tells me that voters fell victim to either anger or malaise.

      Have people been in a coma for the past two (hell, nine) years? I can’t count the number of times I heard someone say, “We survived the other four years,” or “How bad could he really be?”

      Whatever anger that I have regarding the voting age public is less aimed at long time Trump supporters. As misguided as they are (and I guess it isn’t politic to say that) at least they’ve stood for something, as odious as that something is. No, my anger is directed at those who left the top of the ballot blank, or stayed home or voted for a Jill Stein. Smart people walking a darkening street ask themselves what might be around the upcoming corner. We had millions of people who didn’t bother to wonder what might be around the corner and over the result is that over next two to four years they are going to get seriously mugged. Unfortunately they brought the rest of us along.

      Thank you for reading and commenting
      Paul

      Liked by 1 person

Leave a reply to Paul Cancel reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.