March 4, 2025.
Aspiring Fuehrer Donald J. Trump gave a State of the Union Speech before the usual gaggle; members of Congress, the Supreme Court, the Cabinet, a bunch of bemedaled generals and anyone in the world who had nothing better to do. Nothing better to do sounds rather apathetic, but the fact of the matter is that after Trump’s 100 minute harangue, nothing better would have been better.
In general, the State of the Union speech has become an anachronism, a holdover from the olden days that goes back to the early twentieth century. It’s kabuki that’s as yesterday as the telegraph and the Model T.
There’s the traditional grand entrance where members of Congress crowd towards the president, supplicating for the honor to shake the regal hand or touch his sleeve or to be recognized by name by whichever fearless leader is in charge at the time (one would think that Jesus himself was entering the building). During the address, members of the President’s party wait for the perfect pauses so that they can rise as one with thundering applause and huzzahs while the other side sits in smug, seated on their hands, silence.
Beginning with Ronald Reagan, the speech now includes props. Props in the form of people who are supposed to add some sort of real life context to the message. The human prop seated in the gallery stands and waves, while the President relates the human prop’s heartrending story of triumph or tragedy. At the end of the President’s tale, men are shouting praises and women are dabbing their eyes.
At the end of the speech, the President’s party proclaims the speech to be Churchillian, while the other party calls it a collection of hogwash, and the pundits analyze it to death while revealing the misrepresentations, and the outright lies. Afterwards, the opposing party chooses someone to give a televised response.
Historically the State of the Union has been a President’s annual message to Congress and the nation, that is meant to communicate the current condition of the country, and the President’s proposals for the coming year. Until 1912, the State of the Union was not an oratory but a written report submitted to Congress. Given the partisan theater that the State of the Union has become, perhaps the whole thing should revert to a written report.
Continue reading